— Guide
Hiring Risk Signals: What to Check Before You Make an Offer
Culture and manager fit are one kind of hiring risk. This is the rest of it: verifying what's actually true, understanding why someone is really leaving, and knowing which offers are likely to get countered.
By Yuval Ashkenazi, headhunter and HR consultant with a background in psychology Updated
Hiring risk is bigger than fit
Our guide on culture and manager fit covers one specific risk: whether a candidate's working style matches the team and manager. That's one piece of a bigger picture. The rest is verification (is what's on the resume and in the interview actually true), motivation (why is this person really leaving, or really interested), and timing risk (will they actually show up on day one, or take a counteroffer at the last minute).
Skipping this stage doesn't save time. It moves the cost of finding out later, after an offer is signed and a notice period has started, which is the most expensive point for any of this to surface.
Reference checks that actually tell you something
A reference check that asks "would you rehire them" and stops there gets a polite yes almost every time. A useful one asks for a specific example: describe a time this person disagreed with a decision, describe how they handled a missed deadline, describe what surprised the reference, good or bad, after working with them for six months.
Always ask who else the reference would recommend talking to. A candidate who only offers references who reported to them, rather than people who managed them, is itself worth noticing.
For senior or client-facing roles, a reference conversation is worth the extra week it takes to schedule. For roles where the downside of a bad hire is smaller, a lighter check may be proportionate. The point isn't to check every box. It's to match the depth of the check to what's actually at stake.
Verify the story, not just the resume
Numbers on a resume, "grew revenue 40%," "led a team of 12," are claims, not facts, until they're tested. A specific follow-up question, how was that measured, over what period, what was your part versus the team's, usually separates a real result from an inflated one within thirty seconds.
Watch for a story that changes shape between interview rounds. Not every inconsistency is a red flag. People remember things differently under pressure. But a materially different account of the same event, told to two different interviewers, is worth asking about directly rather than letting it slide.
Understand why they're actually leaving, or actually interested
"Looking for new challenges" is rarely the real answer, and a good interview process digs one layer past it: what specifically is missing in the current role, and would a counteroffer that fixed exactly that change their mind. If the honest answer is yes, that's a real signal worth surfacing before an offer goes out, not after it's declined.
The same question in reverse matters for the employer side too: candidates who are vague about why this specific role and this specific company, beyond compensation, are more likely to keep looking even after they accept.
Reduce counteroffer risk before it happens
- Ask directly, before an offer is extended, how the candidate expects their current employer to react, and whether they've thought through what they'd say to a counteroffer.
- Keep the process moving. A long gap between the final interview and the offer gives a current employer more time to find out and react.
- Make sure the offer addresses the real reason they're leaving, not only compensation, since a counteroffer that only matches salary rarely fixes what was actually driving the search.
- Stay in light contact between offer acceptance and the start date. A candidate who goes quiet during a long notice period is a signal worth checking in on, not ignoring.
FAQ
How many references is enough?
Two is a reasonable floor for most roles, three for senior or high-stakes ones. The number matters less than whether the references were chosen by you as well as the candidate.
Should you check references even for a candidate you're confident about?
Especially then. Confidence built entirely on interview performance is exactly the blind spot a reference check exists to catch.
What's a realistic sign that a candidate might take a counteroffer?
Vagueness about compensation as a motivator, hesitation when asked directly how their current manager will react, and a notice period longer than usual are all worth a direct conversation rather than an assumption.
Is it fair to ask a candidate why they're really leaving?
Yes, asked well. The goal isn't to catch them out. It's to understand what they actually need next, which is also the information that predicts whether they'll be satisfied a year into the new role.
Related guides
Hiring at a growth-stage company in Israel and want a second opinion on your next search?
Book a 15-min intro call