— Guide
Hiring Without an HR Team: A Playbook for Operations Managers at Small Companies
At most small companies, hiring falls to whoever runs operations. Nobody trained you for it, it eats more hours than anyone budgets for, and a bad hire hurts a team of 20 far more than a team of 2,000. Here's how to run it well with the time you actually have.
By Yuval Ashkenazi, headhunter and HR consultant with a background in psychology Updated
Nobody planned for you to own hiring
A 25-person company almost never has an HR manager, let alone an in-house recruiter. But roles still need posting, CVs still need reading, interviews still need scheduling, and someone has to close the offer. That someone tends to be the operations manager, the COO or one of the founders, and the work gets squeezed into whatever time is left over. That's how a role that should take six weeks ends up taking four months.
The stakes are higher than they look, too. On a 15-person team, one empty seat is several percent of the company's capacity, and one wrong hire affects everyone who works next to them. A large company absorbs a mis-hire. A small one feels it for a quarter.
A lean process you can actually run
You don't need an applicant tracking system or a competency framework. You need five things settled before the first interview:
- What success looks like six months in. Write down three or four concrete outcomes before you write the job ad. The ad gets better, and so does every interview after it.
- What rules someone out. Agree with the hiring manager on two or three dealbreakers, so screening takes minutes instead of a debate.
- What you'll ask everyone. Use the same short set of questions at each stage, so you're comparing answers, not impressions.
- Who decides, and when. Fix the interview stages and the final decision-maker upfront. At small companies, most delays come down to nobody being sure who makes the call.
- How fast you'll reply. Commit to getting back to every candidate within a few working days. Strong candidates have options, and a slow reply tells them what working for you will feel like.
Where the hours actually go
Posting the ad takes an afternoon. The real time goes into reading dozens of applications that were never a fit, the back-and-forth of finding interview slots, and chasing the hiring manager for feedback.
Then there's the part most small companies never get to. For any role that's even moderately hard to fill, the best people aren't applying. They're doing well somewhere else, and someone has to find them, approach them and make the case for a company they may never have heard of. That takes time and a network an operations manager rarely has to spare, and it's what a headhunter does that a job ad can't.
Signs it's time to get help
- The role has been open for over a month and you still haven't met anyone you'd hire.
- CV screening and interview scheduling have moved into your evenings.
- The hiring manager keeps meeting candidates who should have been screened out at the first step.
- You need three or more hires in the next six months, and operations won't run itself in the meantime.
- It's the first role of its kind at the company, so nobody inside really knows what good looks like.
Which kind of help depends on the problem. One hard or senior role usually calls for a headhunter. A steady stream of roles over the coming months, with nobody to own them, is what managed recruiting (RPO) is for. Headhunter vs. agency and RPO vs. retained search walk through the trade-offs, and the guide to recruitment fees covers what each one costs.
When you compare options, don't stop at the fee. Count your own hours, and what an empty seat or a wrong hire costs the team while the search drags on.
FAQ
We're about 30 people with no HR. Do we need an HR manager before we start hiring?
No. Plenty of companies this size run hiring through operations or a founder and bring in outside help for the hard roles. A full-time HR hire usually makes sense later, once there's enough people work, not just recruiting, to need an owner.
How much of my time will one hire take?
It depends on the role, but screening, scheduling and interviewing for a single mid-level hire can easily add up to dozens of hours over several weeks. If nobody good applies and you have to go out and find people, it takes a lot more.
What's the most common hiring mistake at small companies?
Starting interviews before agreeing on what the role needs to achieve. Without that, every interviewer judges candidates against their own picture of the job, the feedback contradicts itself, and the decision stalls.
Does Yuval HR work with small companies?
Yes, it's the main focus: Israeli tech companies of roughly 10 to 100 people, often where the operations manager or a founder owns hiring. That covers searches for single roles and managed recruiting for ongoing hiring.
Which roles does Yuval HR recruit for?
Every level, across R&D, product, data, marketing, sales, customer success, operations, HR, finance and legal, and creative, from individual contributors to senior leadership.
Related guides
Running hiring on top of everything else? A 15-minute call will tell you whether outside help would actually save you time.
Book a 15-min intro call