— Guide
Job Ad or Headhunter? What Each One Gets a Small Tech Company
Posting a role is free, fast and, for plenty of roles, enough. For the hires that matter most to a small company it often isn't, because the people you want are busy doing well somewhere else.
By Yuval Ashkenazi, headhunter and HR consultant with a background in psychology Updated
The limits of posting and waiting
A job ad only reaches people who are looking right now. That's a real pool, and for some roles it's all you need. But it misses everyone who is doing well where they are and isn't checking job boards, which in a competitive market is often most of the strongest candidates.
The small-company handicap
Small companies have a second problem on top of that. People skim job ads by company name. Next to a household-name employer, an unfamiliar 30-person company rarely gets the click, even when the role, the team and the upside are better. Nobody reads far enough to find out.
A conversation fixes what an ad can't. A strong candidate who would never apply to a company they've never heard of will often take a call from someone who can explain the role, the team and why it's worth a look.
What you're actually paying a headhunter for
- Defining the role with you: the team, the manager and what the person will really walk into, not only the job description.
- Mapping who does this job across the market, and approaching them directly and discreetly.
- Telling your company's story to people who've never heard of it, which is exactly where a small company starts at a disadvantage.
- Screening for fit with the team and the manager, not only for skills on a CV.
- Running the process through to the offer, so the hiring manager only spends time on candidates worth meeting.
Post first, or call someone?
- Posting is usually enough when the role attracts plenty of qualified applicants and good CVs arrive within a week or two.
- A headhunter is worth it for senior roles, the first hire of its kind, roles where the ad has been up for weeks without a strong candidate, confidential replacements, and any hire where getting it wrong would set the team back months.
Plenty of small companies do both: post the role, and bring in a headhunter if the first few weeks don't produce a shortlist.
FAQ
Our job ad has been up for a month and nobody good has applied. What now?
First, check that the ad describes the real job and the real offer. If it does, the people you need probably aren't looking, and the next step is approaching them directly. That's what a headhunter does.
Can a small, unknown company really attract strong candidates through a headhunter?
Yes, and it's one of the main reasons to use one. Strong candidates rarely apply to companies they've never heard of, but they'll often take a call from someone who can explain the role, the team and why it's worth their time.
How do I find a good headhunter for a small tech company in Israel?
Look for someone who works mostly with companies your size, approaches passive candidates rather than only screening applicants, and assesses team and manager fit, not just CVs. How to choose a recruiter lists the questions to ask. Yuval HR focuses on Israeli tech companies of roughly 10 to 100 people, across all levels and functions.
Related guides
Role been open for weeks without a strong candidate? Let's take a look at it together.
Book a 15-min intro call